Becoming Grey: Episode 15

Chapter Fifteen 
November 14th 

Stuart sat on the edge of an exam bed at Ridgemont Medical with his right hand resting carefully across his lap. 

It hurt a lot more now. 

At the Bennett house there had been too much adrenaline for him to notice much beyond the first sharp burst of pain. By the time they reached the clinic, the pain had settled into a deep, steady throb that seemed to pulse with his heartbeat. Swelling spread across his knuckles and down the back of his hand, and two of his fingers had already started turning an ugly shade of purple beneath the skin. 

Someone had taken X-rays twenty minutes ago. Now they were waiting for the doctor to return and confirm what everyone in the room already suspected. 

Stuart had broken something. 

Callie stood against the opposite wall with her arms folded tightly across her stomach. She had barely spoken since they left the Bennett house. Her backpack sat abandoned in the chair beside her, and every few seconds her attention drifted back to her father’s hand no matter how many times she told herself not to look at it. 

Sally stood beside the exam bed. 

She had spent most of the drive alternating between asking Stuart whether he could move his fingers and explaining, with increasing specificity, exactly how stupid it had been to punch Tim Bennett. 

Stuart had mostly accepted this. 

Mostly. 

Callie looked at his hand again and felt the misery roll through her in another wave. 

“Dad, I’m sorry.” Her voice came out rough. “I never thought…” 

Stuart looked up immediately. “Cal.” 

“I never thought any of this was going to happen.” 

“You have nothing to apologize for.” 

“Your hand is broken.” 

“Probably.” 

Sally looked down at him. “Thank you, Doctor Grey.” 

Stuart glanced at the swelling. “I’m just saying, it doesn’t look great.” 

“No, Stuart. It does not look great.” 

Under almost any other circumstances, Callie might have smiled. 

She couldn’t. 

“But it happened because of me.” 

Stuart’s expression changed. “No.” 

“Dad—” 

“No.” He shifted on the exam bed and immediately winced when the movement jostled his hand. “We are not doing that.” 

Callie pushed away from the wall. “If I wasn’t pregnant, we wouldn’t have been at their house. If I hadn’t—” 

“If I hadn’t punched Tim Bennett, my hand wouldn’t be broken.” 

She stopped. 

“That part is mine,” Stuart said. “Not yours.” 

“But he was saying those things because of me.” 

“He was saying those things about you. There’s a difference.” 

Callie looked down at the floor. 

The tiles between her shoes were pale gray, broken into little squares with dark lines between them. She focused on one because looking at her father’s hand made her stomach hurt. 

“You made a mistake,” Stuart said. 

The words still stung. 

He continued before she could disappear into herself. “A big one. Your mom and I aren’t pretending otherwise. You made choices we’re disappointed in, and there are consequences you’re going to be dealing with for a long time.” 

Callie swallowed. 

“But making a mistake doesn’t make you what Tim was trying to make you out to be.” 

She looked up. 

Stuart’s jaw tightened. 

“You are not some girl who targeted their son. You didn’t trick him. You didn’t force yourself on him. And you sure as hell aren’t a whore like Tim was dancing around because he didn’t have the guts to actually say it.” 

“Stuart,” Sally said quietly. 

“What? That’s what he was doing.” 

“I know.” 

Callie looked at her mother. 

Something about Sally agreeing made her throat tighten all over again. 

Stuart looked directly at Callie. “He wanted you sitting there while he told everybody what kind of girl he thought you were. He knew you could hear him.” 

Callie rubbed one sleeve against the other. 

“And then you knocked him down.” 

Sally folded her arms. “Also established.” 

Callie looked at Stuart again. “I’ve never seen you hit anyone.” 

Stuart was quiet for a moment. 

“Neither has your mother.” 

“That’s because normal people don’t solve arguments by breaking their hands on somebody’s face.” 

“I know, Sal.” 

“No, I’m going to keep saying it because apparently this is something that needs reinforcing.” 

Stuart looked down at his swollen hand and tried to flex his fingers. His face tightened almost immediately. 

“Don’t do that,” Sally said. 

“I wanted to see if I could.” 

“You can’t.” 

“Apparently.” 

“Because you punched somebody.” 

“Yes, Sally.” 

“Just making sure we’re following the chain of events.” 

Stuart sighed. “You can reinforce it all you want. I’m still not apologizing.” 

Sally’s expression hardened slightly. “I didn’t ask you to apologize to Tim.” 

“I know. But you want me to say I should’ve walked away.” 

“You should have.” 

“No.” 

The answer came so quickly that Callie looked up. 

Sally stared at him. 

Stuart met her eyes. “No. I shouldn’t have.” 

“Stuart.” 

“I asked him to stop. I asked him to take it back. I asked him to apologize to Callie. More than once.” His voice remained controlled, but Callie could hear the anger underneath it again. “He knew exactly what he was saying. He knew exactly who was sitting in that room listening to him. And every time I gave him a chance to stop, he went further.” 

Callie lowered her eyes. 

Stuart noticed. 

His voice softened. “Cal, I’m not saying this because I want you thinking about those words again. But I’m also not going to pretend Tim was making some reasonable argument about responsibility. He was calling you a whore without having the guts to actually use the word.” 

The bluntness of it made Callie’s face burn. 

Sally let out a slow breath but didn’t contradict him. 

“That’s what he meant,” Stuart continued. “He wanted everybody in that room to understand exactly what he thought you were.” 

Callie nodded once. 

She hated that her father was right. 

Sally rubbed one hand against her forehead. “That still doesn’t mean you had to hit him.” 

“No,” Stuart said. “It means I made a choice.” 

“A bad one.” 

“A costly one.” 

“There’s a difference?” 

“There is to me.” 

Sally stared at him. 

Stuart lifted his injured hand a fraction and winced. “This is the consequence of my choice. I hit him. I broke my hand. If there are other consequences, I’ll deal with those too.” 

“You make that sound very simple.” 

“It is simple.” 

“No, it isn’t.” 

“Sal, I’m not saying everybody should start swinging whenever somebody says something they don’t like.” 

“Good. Wonderful. We’ve established one basic rule of civilization.” 

Despite everything, Callie felt the smallest pull at the corner of her mouth. 

Stuart saw it but kept his attention on Sally. “I’m saying people love telling you to walk away like walking away solves every situation.” 

“A lot of the time, it does.” 

“I agree.” 

That seemed to surprise Sally enough that she stopped for a second. 

Stuart continued. “Most arguments aren’t worth it. Somebody cuts you off in traffic, walk away. Some idiot gets mouthy at the store, walk away. Somebody calls me every name they can think of, I really don’t care.” 

He looked toward Callie. 

“But not everything is that.” 

Callie held his gaze. 

“Tim wanted us to walk away,” Stuart said. “He wanted to sit there, tell Callie what kind of person she was, hand us those papers, and have us quietly leave while he got to believe every word he said was acceptable.” 

“You could have taken Callie and left without accepting anything.” 

“And then what?” 

Sally frowned. 

“What happens tomorrow?” Stuart asked. “What happens next week when half the town knows? If Tim Bennett was willing to look me in the eye and say those things about my daughter while she was sitting three feet away, what do you think he says when none of us are there?” 

Callie’s stomach tightened. 

Sally’s expression changed slightly. 

“What does he tell his friends?” Stuart continued. “People at work? Other parents? What story does Myles hear every night until that becomes his version too?” 

Callie looked down again. 

“Callie is the one who has to walk into Ridgemont High,” Stuart said. “She’s the one who has to hear whispers in the hallway. She’s the one who has to wonder if everybody staring at her heard some version of Tim’s story where his innocent son got trapped by the horrible girl who seduced him.” 

Callie pressed her lips together. 

“Dad…” 

“No.” Stuart’s voice softened. “You shouldn’t have to pretend that doesn’t matter just because adults are supposed to keep everything polite.” 

Sally crossed her arms. “And punching Tim keeps people from talking?” 

“No.” 

“Then what did it accomplish?” 

Stuart considered the question. 

“It told Tim where the line was.” 

“With your fist.” 

“Yes.” 

“Stuart.” 

“I warned him.” 

“That does not magically make punching someone okay.” 

“I didn’t say it did.” 

“You’re getting dangerously close.” 

Stuart shook his head. “No. I’m saying physical force isn’t the first tool in the box. It shouldn’t be the second or third either. But I’m not going to lie to Callie and tell her there is never a situation where it becomes a valid tool just because that makes for a nicer lesson.” 

Sally stared at him. 

Callie looked between them. 

“The lesson isn’t ‘hit somebody when they make you angry,’” Stuart continued. “The lesson is that your actions have consequences and sometimes you have to decide which consequences you can live with.” 

His eyes dropped toward his hand. 

“I can live with this.” 

Sally’s eyebrows rose. “Your hand might disagree.” 

“It definitely disagrees.” 

“You’re probably going to be in a cast.” 

“Probably.” 

“You run a grocery store.” 

“I’m aware.” 

“You do realize how many things require two hands?” 

“I’m becoming increasingly aware.” 

“And yet?” 

“And yet I can live with it.” 

Sally was quiet. 

Stuart looked at Callie again. 

What I couldn’t live with would be remembering that I stood there and let another man tear into my daughter because walking away would’ve been easier.” 

Something tightened behind Callie’s ribs. 

“You did make a scene,” Sally said. 

“A pretty significant one.” 

“You knocked a grown man unconscious.” 

“I don’t think he was unconscious.” 

“He was on the floor trying to remember what year it was.” 

“That’s not technically unconscious.” 

“Do you want me to hit your other hand?” 

Stuart actually smiled. 

Callie made a small sound before she could stop herself. 

Sally looked at her. 

Callie covered her mouth. 

“Sorry.” 

“Don’t encourage him.” 

“I’m not.” 

“You are absolutely encouraging him.” 

Stuart’s smile disappeared as he looked back at Callie. “Listen to me. What Tim said about you was wrong. Not because you’ve never made mistakes. Not because your mom and I approve of every decision that got us here. We don’t.” 

Callie nodded. 

“But there is a difference between making a bad decision and being a bad person.” 

Her eyes burned. 

“And there is a difference between being disappointed in you and being ashamed of you.” 

That hurt in an entirely different way. 

“Dad…” 

“I am not ashamed of you.” 

A tear escaped before Callie could stop it. 

She wiped it away quickly. 

Stuart continued. “I’m not sorry I defended you either.” 

Sally shifted beside him. 

He looked at her. “I know you disagree.” 

“I disagree with the method.” 

“Fair.” 

“I disagree very strongly with the method.” 

“Also fair.” 

“And I reserve the right to remind you of the method every single time you complain about that hand for the next six weeks.” 

“Also fair.” 

“But?” 

Stuart drew a slow breath. “But I’m not apologizing for hitting him.” 

Sally held his gaze. 

“I’m sorry Callie had to see it,” he continued. “I’m sorry I scared her. I’m sorry you had to pull me back. I’m sorry I broke my hand because apparently I punch like an idiot who doesn’t understand basic anatomy.” 

“You do.” 

“But I will never apologize for defending my daughter’s honor.” 

Callie’s throat tightened again. 

Stuart looked at her. 

“Not yours. Not your mother’s. Not Hannah’s. Nobody gets to stand in front of me and talk about my girls that way and expect me to smile politely, shake their hand, and walk away.” 

Sally sighed. “You are unbelievably stubborn.” 

“You married me.” 

“I was young.” 

“Poor judgment.” 

“Clearly.” 

Callie watched them, unsettled by how ordinary they still sounded. 

Her mother disagreed with what her father had done. Her father knew she disagreed and was apparently prepared to argue about it until his hand healed. Less than an hour ago he had punched another father hard enough to drop him in his own living room, and now they were sitting beneath fluorescent lights at Ridgemont Medical arguing like Sally and Stuart had argued over a hundred smaller things before. 

Yet somehow they were still her parents. 

Still Sally and Stuart. 

Still themselves. 

And beneath all of it was something Callie understood now with absolute certainty. 

Her father was not ashamed of her. 

Not even a little. 

Callie wiped beneath her eyes again. “When he said all that stuff…” 

Both of her parents went quiet. 

“I thought maybe everybody was thinking it.” 

Sally’s face changed immediately. “Oh, Cal.” 

“I know you guys said you weren’t.” Callie stared down at the sleeves gathered around her hands. “But then his parents kept saying it, and Myles wasn’t really saying anything, and…” She struggled for the words. “I started wondering if that’s what everybody’s going to think when they find out.” 

Stuart slid carefully off the exam bed. 

Sally reached for his good arm. “What are you doing?” 

“Standing up.” 

“You’re at a medical clinic because apparently you can’t be trusted with your own limbs.” 

“My legs are fine.” 

“For now.” 

Stuart crossed the small space between himself and Callie. With his injured hand held awkwardly against his body, he wrapped his left arm around her shoulders and pulled her against him. 

Callie went without resisting. 

“You listen to me,” he said. 

She rested her forehead against his chest. 

“You are probably going to hear some things over the next few months that you don’t deserve to hear. Some people are going to judge you. Some people are going to hear one thing about your life and decide that tells them everything they need to know about you.” 

Callie closed her eyes. 

“I can’t stop all of that.” 

His arm tightened around her. 

“But none of those people get to decide who you are. Tim doesn’t. Karen doesn’t. Myles doesn’t. Kids at school sure as hell don’t.” 

Callie swallowed. 

“And your father definitely does not get to punch every person who says something stupid, so don’t misunderstand what I’m telling you.” 

“Thank you,” Sally said. 

Stuart ignored her. 

“But I will always stand up for you.” 

Callie’s fingers closed around the fabric of his shirt. 

“Always.” 

Then Stuart lowered his voice. 

“And for the record, you’re still my little girl.” 

That did it. 

Callie’s face crumpled against his chest. 

She had spent the last week circling that fear without always knowing how to name it. She had been afraid that pregnancy had changed something fundamental, that telling her parents what happened would move her across some invisible line she could never cross back over. Then she had heard Stuart call her his little girl in the Bennett living room seconds before everything exploded. 

Now he was saying it again. 

Not angry. 

Not defending her from anyone. 

Just telling her. 

“I love you, Dad.” 

Stuart kissed the top of her head. 

“I love you too, kiddo.” 

Sally stepped closer and rested a hand against Callie’s back. 

“I love both of you,” she said. “But one of you is grounded from punching people.” 

Stuart looked at her over Callie’s head. “I’m forty-something.” 

“Then I’m sure you’ll appreciate how embarrassing it is to be grounded at your age.” 

Callie laughed. 

Actually laughed. 

It lasted only a second before she wiped at her face again, but it was real. 

A knock sounded at the door. 

All three of them looked toward it. 

The doctor stepped inside carrying a tablet and glanced from Callie wrapped against her father to Sally standing beside them. 

Then his attention settled on Stuart’s hand. 

“Well,” he said, “you were right. It’s broken.” 

Sally gave Stuart a look. 

Stuart sighed. “Of course it is.” 

“Two fractures,” the doctor continued. “Nothing displaced badly enough that I think you’ll need surgery, which is the good news. The less good news is that you’re going to need that hand immobilized for a while.” 

Sally folded her arms again. “How long?” 

The doctor began explaining. 

Callie listened only halfway. 

Her father’s arm was still around her shoulders. 

His hand was broken. The Bennetts hated her. Myles had barely defended her. There were papers sitting somewhere in the Bennett house that could remove him entirely from the baby’s life. School was waiting for her, along with Maggie, Luke, Hannah, and eventually everyone else who would have questions. 

Almost nothing about her life felt simple anymore. But one thing did. She was still Callie Grey. And she was still her father’s little girl. 

Related Images: